Video will appear as you scroll through the story
Lily Allen · S6 E6
The Critics
When the reviews don't match the ambition
May 2014. The reviews for Sheezus are in, and the verdict is almost unanimous: Lily Allen's comeback album doesn't live up to the comeback.
"Everything to Feel Something" by Lily Allen (2018). Years after the Sheezus reviews landed, Lily makes a song that captures what it feels like to pour yourself into your work and come up empty. The production is raw and exposed, stripped of the polish that critics accused Sheezus of having too much of. This is the sound of an artist who knows what it's like to be told her best isn't good enough.
The Verdict
Sheezus debuts at number one on the UK Albums Chart, but the reviews tell a different story. The reviews range from bruising (NME gives it 3 out of 10) to lukewarm (The Guardian awards three stars), with only a handful of outlets like The Daily Telegraph offering genuine praise. The consensus from most critics is harsh: the title promised Kanye-level ambition, and the music didn't match it.
Everything to Feel Something, Lily Allen (2018)
'Everything to Feel Something' is one of the most emotionally exposed tracks in Lily Allen's catalogue. The production is minimal: a simple piano figure, sparse percussion, and a vocal that sits right at the front of the mix with nowhere to hide. Lily sounds exhausted, like someone who has tried every way to feel alive and is running out of options. It's the kind of song critics wished the Sheezus album had more of: honest, unflinching, and completely free of commercial calculation.
TAP TO REVEAL: How did Sheezus perform commercially despite the terrible reviews?
What They Missed
The frustration is that the album does have real moments. 'Hard Out Here' landed perfectly as a cultural statement, the title track started a genuine conversation about women in pop, and deeper cuts like 'Silver Spoon' and 'Close Your Eyes' show a vulnerability the singles never attempt. But the critics didn't hear an album; they heard a collection of tracks that didn't add up to more than the sum of their parts.
Sheezus vs. The Press
Take My Place, Lily Allen
'Take My Place' sits in the middle of the Sheezus tracklist, exactly the kind of track reviewers skipped over on their way to writing about the title. It's a quieter, more personal song that doesn't try to be a single, doesn't try to start a conversation, and doesn't compete with anyone. In an episode about what the critics missed, this is exhibit A.
Take My Place, Lily Allen (2014)
Read the lyrics while you listen. No controversy, no name-drops, no provocation. Just a woman writing a pop song about something that matters to her, which is all Lily Allen ever wanted to do in the first place.
What was Lily Allen's FIRST number one album in the UK?
Sheezus has divided the critics, burned through the headlines, and left Lily Allen standing in the wreckage of her own ambition. Next episode: what this album really cost her, and the reckoning that follows.
0 XP earned this session