Video will appear as you scroll through the story
Eagles · S2 E5
Four Voices
Every member can sing lead. Every member writes. Every member has an ego. The gift and the curse of Eagles
A dressing room somewhere in America, 1972. Four musicians who just sang in perfect harmony onstage sit down to choose the next single, and within ten minutes, four people have four completely different answers.
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, Teach Your Children (1970). The great multi-voice harmony group on the Laurel Canyon scene, and the tradition Eagles inherited. CSNY proved that multiple voices could be the core identity of a band. Eagles took that idea, added a fourth voice, and built something even more ambitious.
The Gift
Every member of Eagles can sing lead. Glenn Frey sounds like Detroit Motown filtered through California sunshine. Don Henley sounds like a Texas poet with gravel in his throat. Bernie Leadon carries the sweetness of country, and Randy Meisner has a high tenor that can break your heart at fifty yards.
“We were a band of four leaders and no followers. In the beginning, that was our greatest strength. Eventually, it became the thing that nearly destroyed us.”
— Don Henley, History of the Eagles documentary, 2013
TAP TO REVEAL: What financial arrangement planted the first seeds of tension inside Eagles?
The Curse
The problem with four lead singers is that every one of them believes they should be the frontman. Frey has the charisma and the business instincts. Henley has the voice and the lyrical depth. Leadon and Meisner watch the Frey-Henley partnership tighten and start to feel like passengers in their own band.
Which member brought country and bluegrass elements to Eagles' sound?
Bitter Creek, Eagles (Desperado, 1973)
Written and sung by Bernie Leadon, this is the strongest example of a voice that was not Frey or Henley taking the spotlight. Leadon's gentle vocal and acoustic guitar create a moment of stillness on an album full of outlaw ambition. It is the sound of the "fourth voice," the one most casual fans forget existed.
Four voices, four writers, four egos, and somehow it all works. Next: instant success and what happens when a band of unknowns becomes the face of California rock overnight.
0 XP earned this session