Video will appear as you scroll through the story
Fleetwood Mac · S8 E6
The Producer
Lindsey Buckingham: no pick, all fingers, and an obsession with layering that turned a pop band into something no one could replicate
A converted garage in the Hollywood Hills, 1985. Lindsey Buckingham sits alone with a four-track recorder, layering guitar parts until three in the morning, building what he thinks is a solo album but what will become Fleetwood Mac's second-biggest record.
"Whole Lotta Trouble" (Stevie Nicks, official music video, 1989). This is what Stevie sounds like without Lindsey Buckingham producing her. Rupert Hine handles the controls, and the result is polished, professional, and missing something you can't quite name. That something is the thing this episode is about.
The Man Who Heard Things Nobody Else Could
Lindsey Buckingham never learned to play guitar with a pick. He uses his fingers, all five of them, attacking the strings from multiple angles at once. That self-taught technique became the foundation of a production style that nobody has successfully copied: dense, layered, obsessively detailed, and somehow still warm underneath all the complexity.
Sources
Guitar World. "Lindsey Buckingham: The Art of Fingerpicking." 2006.
Fleetwood, Mick. "Play On: Now, Then, and Fleetwood Mac." Little, Brown, 2014.
“Lindsey hears the finished record before a single note has been played. The rest of us are just trying to keep up with what's already inside his head.”
— Christine McVie, Rolling Stone interview, 1987
Whole Lotta Trouble, Stevie Nicks (1989)
"Whole Lotta Trouble" was produced by Rupert Hine for The Other Side of the Mirror, and it's a perfectly good rock song: tight, catchy, well-arranged. But compare it to anything Lindsey produced for Stevie with Fleetwood Mac and you hear the difference instantly. The guitars sit politely in the mix instead of attacking from every angle. The drums sound programmed rather than alive. It's the production equivalent of a well-lit room versus a room full of candles. One is professional; the other is magic.
Sources
Davis, Stephen. "Gold Dust Woman: The Biography of Stevie Nicks." St. Martin's Press, 2017.
The Other Side of the Mirror, liner notes. Modern Records, 1989.
TAP TO REVEAL: How did Lindsey Buckingham record Tango in the Night?
The Cost of Control
Lindsey's obsessive production made Fleetwood Mac's records extraordinary, but it also made them nearly impossible to finish. Tusk took over a year and cost more than a million dollars. Tango in the Night took eighteen months. By the time each album was done, the rest of the band could barely stand to be near him.
Sources
Holden, Stephen. "Lindsey Buckingham: The Perfectionist." The New York Times, 1987.
Fleetwood, Mick. "Play On: Now, Then, and Fleetwood Mac." Little, Brown, 2014.
Lindsey Buckingham's Home Studio, Bel Air
The home studio in Bel Air where Lindsey has recorded most of his solo albums and large portions of Tango in the Night. For decades, this converted space has been his laboratory, the place where he builds songs layer by layer without anyone else's input.
Lindsey Buckingham: The Numbers
The Ledge, Fleetwood Mac (1979)
This is Lindsey at his most unhinged on Tusk: a raw, frantically strummed track that sounds more like punk than anything Fleetwood Mac had done before. He recorded it largely alone, layering acoustic guitars until the sound distorted and buzzed. The rest of the band thought he was losing his mind. Critics at the time dismissed it. Forty years later, it sounds like a producer who was simply ahead of everyone else in the room.
The Ledge, Fleetwood Mac (1979)
The lyrics are barely there: fragments, exclamations, half-finished thoughts that feel more like vocal textures than traditional songwriting. That's the point. On "The Ledge," the voice is just another instrument in Lindsey's wall of sound. The words matter less than the energy, and the energy is pure adrenaline. It's the closest Fleetwood Mac ever came to sounding dangerous.
How did Lindsey Buckingham record the other band members' parts on Tango in the Night?
Lindsey Buckingham turned Fleetwood Mac into something no other band has ever sounded like. Next episode: five people who couldn't stay together and couldn't stay apart, and why the most dysfunctional band in rock history still matters.
0 XP earned this session