Video will appear as you scroll through the story
Madonna · S4 E3
Papa Don't Preach
The pro-life/pro-choice firestorm — what the song actually says, and what politicians made of it
A radio programmer in the Midwest, summer 1986. He puts the needle on the new Madonna single expecting another dance track, but instead a teenage girl asks her father for permission to keep her baby, and his phone lines light up before the song is over.
"Bad Girl" (1993). Directed by David Fincher, the video follows a woman destroying herself through reckless choices while a guardian angel, played by Christopher Walken, watches and does nothing. Seven years after "Papa Don't Preach," Madonna returns to the theme of a woman making choices the world disapproves of. But this time the consequences are fatal, and nobody is asking for permission.
The Song She Did Not Write
Brian Elliot, a relatively unknown songwriter, writes "Papa Don't Preach" as a story-song about a young woman telling her father she is pregnant and keeping the baby. Madonna hears the demo and immediately recognizes its power: it is the kind of song that makes people argue. She reworks the melody and lyric with Patrick Leonard, sharpening the emotional stakes until the father-daughter dynamic cuts like a conversation overheard through a wall.
TAP TO REVEAL: Which institution publicly condemned "Papa Don't Preach"?
“Bringing up a topic for discussion is not the same as telling someone what to do. The fact that people read it that way says more about them than it does about the song.”
— Madonna, on the "Papa Don't Preach" backlash
Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island
The "Papa Don't Preach" music video is shot partly at Fort Wadsworth on Staten Island, with the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge visible in the background. Director James Foley films Madonna in a stripped-down, working-class setting that is deliberately unglamorous. The location grounds the song in a real neighborhood, a real bridge, a real conversation.
Papa by the Numbers
Jimmy Jimmy
From True Blue (1986). The deep cut buried on side two that nobody talks about. A throwaway pop song about a boy who cannot commit, it is the lightest thing on an album loaded with heavy themes. After the weight of "Papa Don't Preach" and "Live to Tell," this track feels like Madonna catching her breath. Stephen Bray's production bounces with a Motown energy that connects all the way back to her Michigan childhood.
What distinctive sound opens "Papa Don't Preach" before Madonna's vocal enters?
The controversy makes her bigger, but it also makes her a target. Next episode: the Who's That Girl film and tour, and the moment Madonna learns that Hollywood does not forgive the way the music industry does.
0 XP earned this session