Video will appear as you scroll through the story
The Beatles · S8 E2
Penny Lane
Paul's answer: a sun-drenched portrait of Liverpool with a piccolo trumpet solo. The double A-side single that is too good for any album
It's a January evening in 1967, and Paul McCartney is slumped on his sofa watching a BBC2 broadcast of Bach's Brandenburg Concerto No. 2 when a piccolo trumpet cuts through the music like a beam of light. By morning, George Martin is on the phone to the man playing it.
"The Fool on the Hill" (The Beatles, 1967). This is Paul at his most Paul: a simple, almost childlike melody hiding surprising harmonic depth. Filmed during the Magical Mystery Tour sessions, it captures the same melodic instinct that drives "Penny Lane." Watch how McCartney turns a lone figure on a hill into something cinematic with nothing but his voice and a recorder. This is the songwriter who painted all of Penny Lane from memory.
The Fool on the Hill, The Beatles (1967)
Paul wrote the core melody on piano in March 1967, during the final Sgt. Pepper sessions, but the song wasn't completed until September. The arrangement is deceptively bare: just piano, recorder, flutes, and a finger-cymbal that Paul picked up in India. Underneath that simplicity, the harmony does something unusual: the verse sits in D major but keeps slipping into D minor and back, giving the melody its bittersweet, drifting quality. Listen for the three recorder parts, all played by Paul, layered on top of each other to create that fluttery, almost pastoral texture.
Sources
Lewisohn, Mark. "The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions." Hamlyn, 1988.
MacDonald, Ian. "Revolution in the Head." Chicago Review Press, 2005.
Paul's Answer
John has just finished "Strawberry Fields Forever," a swirling, surreal trip back to a Salvation Army children's home near his childhood house. Paul hears it and thinks: I can do Liverpool too, but my way. Where John goes inward and abstract, Paul goes outward and observational. His Liverpool is a street full of characters you can see, hear, and almost smell.
Sources
Miles, Barry. "Many Years From Now." Secker & Warburg, 1997.
“Penny Lane is not just a street. To us it was a place we all knew. John and I would get the bus there. It was a terminus. You'd get the 86 bus to Penny Lane.”
— Paul McCartney
The Piccolo Trumpet
The song sounds effortlessly sunny, but underneath it's doing something wild with key changes. It modulates constantly mid-verse and between choruses in ways that most pop songs wouldn't dare attempt. Listen for the way the piano drives everything forward, how the flutes and oboes weave around Paul's vocal, and then how David Mason's piccolo trumpet blasts through the middle section like nothing you've heard in pop music before.
Sources
Lewisohn, Mark. "The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions." Hamlyn, 1988.
Gould, Jonathan. "Can't Buy Me Love." Crown, 2007.
TAP TO REVEAL: How much did David Mason earn for the most famous trumpet solo in pop history?
Penny Lane, Liverpool
The real street where the barber shop, the bank, and the fire station from the lyrics still stand. Fans have stolen the street sign so many times that the city eventually painted the name directly onto the buildings.
Penny Lane
She's Leaving Home, The Beatles (1967)
If "Penny Lane" is Paul painting a neighborhood in watercolors, "She's Leaving Home" is Paul directing a short film. Written after he read a Daily Mail story about a 17-year-old runaway named Melanie Coe, it's a miniature domestic drama told from two perspectives: the daughter slipping out the back door, and the parents waking up to find her gone. No Beatle plays a single instrument on it, just strings and harp arranged by Mike Leander because George Martin was busy recording Cilla Black. Martin was hurt, but he still conducted the session.
She's Leaving Home, The Beatles (1967)
"She's leaving home after living alone for so many years." Paul read the story of Melanie Coe in the Daily Mail on February 27, 1967, and wrote the song that same day. In a twist nobody could have scripted, Coe had actually appeared on television years earlier as a teenager, winning a mime competition on Ready Steady Go! that was judged by Paul McCartney himself. He had no idea when he wrote the song that he'd already met the girl it was about.
What classical piece inspired Paul to add a piccolo trumpet to 'Penny Lane'?
The Cruel Irony
"Penny Lane" was originally meant for Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, but manager Brian Epstein needed a new single to keep the Beatles visible after months of studio silence. Once released, the band's own rule kicked in: no singles on albums. George Martin later said he believed "When I'm Sixty-Four" and "Lovely Rita" would have been dropped to make room. Imagine that version of Sgt. Pepper.
Sources
The Beatles Bible, "Penny Lane / Strawberry Fields Forever single."
Lewisohn, Mark. "The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions." Hamlyn, 1988.
It took 700 hours in Abbey Road Studios, an orchestra that didn't know what hit them, and a Peter Blake cover that cost more than most albums did to record. Next time: "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band," the album the entire world listened to at exactly the same moment.
0 XP earned this session